Is Sapphire Really the Best Choice for the iPhone 6 Screen?

iphone 6 screen

The rumor mill that’s been sending out fresh iPhone 6 guesses has been going at full speed lately. The biggest rumor seems to be centered around what material Apple will use for the screen of the future. If the gossip is to be believed we have a shiny sapphire screen to look forward to, but is that really a feasible option and above this, is it even the best choice for the iPhone 6 screen?

So What is Sapphire?

Sapphire is a gemstone made from aluminum oxide. Trace amounts of iron and other minerals give sapphire it’s striking color, making it a perfect choice for jewelry.

It might be hard to understand how a gemstone can become the screen for your next iPhone, but what you have to understand is that sapphire on your iPhone is pretty different from the sapphire in a ring or pendant. Many gemstones today can be manufactured as well as found in nature, which allows for very specific thickness and clarity to be given to the material in preparation for life as an iPhone screen.

Gemstones are generally measured on Moh’s scale of mineral hardness that ranges from 1-10 with 1 being the weakest and 10 being the strongest. For reference a diamond is a 10 and sapphire, being an offshoot of corundum, is a 9.

 

SEE ALSO: How Strong is Sapphire?

 

Why Use Sapphire?

iphone 6 screen sapphire

The biggest complaint about smartphones in general next to battery life is scratched and cracked screens. Corning’s current Gorilla Glass is great, but when put through the paces of our daily lives, it can fail with a good drop or with some time spent in a pocket or purse with car keys.

Sapphire is far more impact and scratch resistant, making it a pretty obvious choice for a screen that needs to stand up to the daily abuse that our phones do. Currently sapphire is most commonly used in the crystals of high-end watches like Tag Heuer, but currently Apple uses sapphire in the touch sensor on the iPhone 5S and the cameras in the 5, 5S, and 5C.

As we mentioned above, sapphire is a 9 on the Moh’s hardness scale, meaning that only diamond can scratch it. This alone makes sapphire a great choice for something that gets scratched and dropped so often, but there are still some downsides.

 

SEE ALSO: The 10 Most Useful Defaults Write Commands for OS X

 

Issues With Sapphire

The biggest issue with sapphire is the cost. The current methods to produce sapphire put it at about ten times the cost of Gorilla Glass. For a company that made the iPhone 5C to save money, this doesn’t seem like a feasible choice.

Next to cost there are some issues with clarity and weight. Sapphire currently weights more than glass and while the difference isn’t huge, every ounce counts. As for clarity, sapphire tends to be darker, letting less light through. This was supposedly the issue with the sapphire lens on the iPhone 5, 5S, and 5C when it was darkening pictures and adding a touch of purple to them.

The last big issue has to do with the production of the sapphire itself. Glass is produced in an endless loop of creation, with most plants rarely if ever shuttering the production line. This means that issues can be seen and fixed easily and quickly. If there’s an issue with a batch of sapphire, it’s all a waste. Sapphire also takes far more energy to create, bringing eco-friendly practices into question, too.

 

SEE ALSO: What We Know About the iPhone 6 So Far

 

What is the Alternative?

iphone 6 screen

As mentioned above the best alternative is Corning’s Gorilla Glass. The current leader in smart phone screen technology touts 2,400 product models and 2.4 billion devices with Gorilla Glass.

Basically Gorilla Glass is regular glass that’s chemically treated and strengthened via a compression layer that covers the surface of the glass. The tests that Gorilla Glass can withstand are pretty amazing to say the least, so why isn’t anyone talking about this material in the next iPhone?

Will Sapphire Work?

iphone-6-screen-testing

Technically yes. The next iPhone could have a sapphire screen. Apple recently purchased a plant in Arizona that produces sapphire so there’s a good chance they’d have enough of the material to build a new iPhone, with a catch.

The inherent issues with sapphire are price and darkness. If Apple were to use a thin layer of sapphire over a standard glass screen, it could be the best of both worlds. The surface of the iPhone would be insanely strong while the sapphire would be thin enough to not interfere with brightness.

There are companies that produce screen protectors made from sapphire currently, but they are somewhat expensive and one thing Apple has stuck with is the iPhone pricing, meaning that a price increase is not likely.

Would a sapphire screen on the iPhone 6 work? Possibly, but with the current downsides to sapphire it’s not likely. Apple needs to focus on profit and innovation and sapphire in an iPhone screen wouldn’t fit either.

Most likely Apple is planning on using this sapphire for a new project like the iWatch, which would make far more sense. The rumor mill is in full swing and until we see the iWatch or iPhone 6, it’s all up for debate and speculation. Is sapphire really the best choice for the iPhone 6? All signs point to no.

About Brian Meyer

Brian is a technology nut who loves all things Apple. Along with tech blogging he owns and operates a website dedicated to Craft Beer knowledge and information: Craft Beer Academy. With a love of sharing information and finding the newest tech out there, he is a great source for interesting news and instruction.

Comments

  1. Constable Odo says:

    Corning must certainly be thinking Apple will be using a sapphire screen on the iPhone 6 or they wouldn’t have made such a big stink about how Apple is heading for a major disaster by not going with Gorilla Glass. I’ll bet Corning is totally pissed that Apple won’t renew their Gorilla Glass contract in the future. I may be going out on a limb but if Apple really is thinking of using a sapphire display for the iPhone then I’m fairly certain Apple must have done their homework before sinking a billion or so into sapphire-making furnaces. I know sapphire can be used for many other critical things so the money sure won’t go to waste. I just tend to think Apple knows what it is doing by making such a huge decision to go with sapphire displays. I’m basically hoping Apple and G.T. Advanced Technologies, Inc. have come up with some breakthrough product that will shut up all the naysayer’s mouths.

    • I agree totally, but the major point is that we don’t know what that sapphire will be for. Could be iWatch, could be rolling out touch sensors and sapphire camera shields on iPads. Heck, could be doing sapphire touch sensors on Macs now, too!

  2. LOL. T is fair to question what Apple does, I find it funny that a blogger thinks they know better than all the material scientists working for GTE and Apple.

    The purple effect in the cameras was not due to the use of sapphire.

    Impurity free Al2O3 is very transparent, especially given how thin the layer is. Go to any jewelry shop and look at the sapphire covers on high end watches.

    If sapphire is denser than GG it is not by much. I’ve analyzed GG. It contains silicon and potassium, among other things, which are heavier than aluminum. On top of that this layer is so thin that the difference in weight will be minuscule.

    • Noemi Tasarra-Twigg says:

      I find it unfair to say a blogger “thinks they know better than all the material scientists working for GTE and Apple.” It’s his opinion, and yes, everyone has one.

    • A few things.
      1. I don’t think I know better than them in regard to application of and production of sapphire, but sometimes the public at large does know better than Apple. Take the iPhone 5C for example. Touted as the best thing going and it’s mostly a flop.

      2. From everything I’ve read on the camera issue, nobody really knows why this happened 100%. Odd light angles on the sapphire cover, paired with whatever they have to coat it with for antiglare is a definite possibility. Software corrected the issue, at any rate.

      3. We don’t know how thin the layer will be. The whole screen could be sapphire, or it could be a thin layer paired with glass. Since we don’t know I speculated, just like you did when you assume they will use a thin layer.

      There’s a lot more information on this here: http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/176504-why-apple-is-investing-in-sapphire-glass-for-the-iphone-6-and-why-corning-should-be-nervous

Speak Your Mind

*